View Single Post
  #33 (permalink)   Report Post  
Posted to rec.food.cooking
ImStillMags ImStillMags is offline
Banned
 
Posts: 5,466
Default On bringing your own unrequested food to the holiday dinner

On Tuesday, December 13, 2016 at 9:40:35 AM UTC-8, wrote:
> Not a potluck, of course.
>
> I generally agree with the columnist, but I do think it's only fair and normal for a guest to expect at least ONE non-meat dish, even if it's just salad. (Though if the host is only in the habit of cooking carnivore-style meals, it might be better just to decline the invitation - but the host makes it clear there are all kinds of dishes.) Besides, I have NEVER heard that the rule of "eating what you're served" means having to eat, say, steak (as opposed to something with bouillon) when you don't eat meat. The author would certainly not suggest that guests should violate their own religious dietary principles - what's the difference?
>
> Also, if he were the host and had brand-new guests (not the case here), I think it would only makes sense for him to ASK in advance what the guests don't eat, for any reason, if only to avoid any health problems. I wonder why this hasn't always been the rule for hosts - food allergies may be more common now, but haven't they always existed?
>
> On the flip side, Miss Manners once told a meat-eating guest that no, it is not rude for a vegetarian host to serve only vegetables and that at such a dinner, you'd wouldn't be eating anything unusual anyway.
>
> http://www.gastongazette.com/enterta...k-holiday-host
>
>
> Q: My husband and I are looking forward to hosting our children and grandchildren over the Holidays€”or were. We were recently informed that our 30-something daughter and two of her children have decided to go completely €śvegan€ť and gluten-free and will only eat food that is devoid of any and all animal and wheat products. I have always cooked for omnivores. Now Im informed that I must prepare one meal for 10 people and another entirely separate meal for three people. Furthermore, my daughter has informed me that should I regard cooking two meals as a hassle, they will bring their own food. Am I right in thinking that theres something very self-centered about telling someone they must cooperate in your dietary choices or you will bring your own food? If so, what is your advice?
>
> A: Your assessment of this situation is right on target. But you need to understand €” if you dont already €” that teaching proper manners to children is no longer the norm. Putting consideration of others before consideration of ones self began to go down the child-rearing drain in the 1970s. Even if you raised your daughter to know better, the culture now exerts more influence upon her than her upbringing.
>
> It is inconsiderate to expect ones host to cooperate in dietary preferences that are just that €” preferences. Its one thing if eating vegan and/or gluten-free is a medical necessity. But if the person in question is not going to break out in a pox, go into convulsions or die if he eats something containing meat, milk, butter, cheese, or wheat, then said person ought to take a diet holiday when he/she is a guest in someone elses home. And that includes bringing ones own food€”in this case, refusing to participate in a special, once-a-year meal that you have taken some pains to prepare.
>
> There is a distinct whiff of narcissism to this. But keep in mind that youre dealing with Generation Entitlement. If informed that expecting you to cater to arbitrary food €śissues€ť is inconsiderate, the strong likelihood is that you will be told in one way or another that you are unreasonable, rigid, uncompromising, and worse. In other words, you will become the bad actor. Furthermore, the very persons who need to re-evaluate their behavior will see no need to do so and, in fact, will probably pump themselves up with a surfeit of self-righteousness.
>
> When they were living under our roof, my wife and I told our children that a guest in someones home eats what the host prepares, even if the guest doesnt really care for the food in question. To do otherwise is rude. If a guest has a medical issue that requires certain dietary considerations, said guest is obligated to inform the host well in advance so that an accommodation can be made without haste. But that was then, and this is now, and now is all about individuality.
>
> So, the choice you face is one of simply rolling with this peccadillo or making an issue of it. I advise you to just roll with it. Tell your daughter youd be forever grateful if shed bring the necessary food. Oh, and tell them to bring their own stove and oven while theyre at it.
>
> Just kidding, of course €” in the spirit of the Holidays.
>
> (end)
>
>
>
> Lenona.


I'm sorry but this is just an ego trip. If someone brings a dish I would put it among the others and thank them profusely.