Super Size Me
zxcvbob wrote:
>
> Default User wrote:
> > mrbog wrote:
> >
> >>This guy, and this "study" is ridiculous. Look, McDonalds sells
> >>salads, parfaits (which is yogurt and granola), and even has the
> >>mclean "lowfat" burger. Why didn't he eat that? That's "McDonalds
> >>food" too.
> >
> >
> > If you read his web site about the movie, you see this point:
> >
> >
> > 3) No excuses: he had to eat every item on the menu at least once
> >
> >
> > So he did eat the items you mention, if they were available where he
> > was. The point wasn't, "can you generate a healty meal there?" You
> > probably can, but what are vast vast vast majority of people at
> > McDonalds ordering? The same kind of stuff that wrecked him. Go stand in
> > line, report back how many people were getting salads and yogurt vs. Big
> > Macs and fries.
> >
> >
> > Brian Rodenborn
>
> How many people eat there more than once a day? (BTW, I suspect his
> girlfriend was disgusted with him before all this)
Very few, but that doesn't really matter. Once a day is pretty bad.
The goal of the docu-editorial was to make a point about the fast food
industry. And that is that the increasing (and believe it, it
increasing) reliance of Americans on fast food as a major portion of
their diet is unhealthy, and just exactly how unhealthy it is.
As pointed out above, you can get a pretty healthy meal there, but few
people do.
Was the test outside the norm? Sure. Does that invalidate what he says?
No.
Brian Rodenborn
|