Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
![]() |
|
Barbecue (alt.food.barbecue) Discuss barbecue and grilling--southern style "low and slow" smoking of ribs, shoulders and briskets, as well as direct heat grilling of everything from burgers to salmon to vegetables. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
<http://www.coleman.com/coleman/colemancom/detail.asp?product_id=9990-646>
Exclusively available at Lowes, which doesn't sound like a good thing, but it appears to be functionally equivalent to the 7700: <http://www.coleman.com/coleman/colemancom/detail.asp?product_id=9992-646> I'm trying not to be in the market, but the "two grills in one" with a deep fat fryer/steamer really intrigue me. Anyone? Anyone? Bueller? Matthew |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Hi Matt
I am also looking at this grill. I saw it the other day at Loew's. The one they had out on display also had the rotiserie motor and spit setup. If it really comes with the deep fat fryer AND the rotiserie in the standard 499.00 package then this might be the grill for me. I also am skeptical about the dual cooking areas. I also noticed that it had no thermometer. I would love to hear more on this thread. Anyone else??? Bruce |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"bruman" > wrote in message
lkaboutcooking.com... > Hi Matt > > I am also looking at this grill. I saw it the other day at Loew's. The one > they had out on display also had the rotiserie motor and spit setup. If it > really comes with the deep fat fryer AND the rotiserie in the standard > 499.00 package then this might be the grill for me. I also am skeptical > about the dual cooking areas. I also noticed that it had no thermometer. I > would love to hear more on this thread. > > Anyone else??? > > Bruce Consumer reports rated the $279 Lowes Coleman grill highly for the money. But when I went looking the only Coleman in stock was the $399 one, (similar to the one you ask about but without the fryer and rotisserie, and a bit smaller). I finally decided that for $279 I'd take the chance, but there were construction features I didn't like in a grill that cost much more than that. Mainly the cheap feeling lid, including lightweight end castings, and simple hinge pin arrangement - doesn't seem 4-500 dollar sturdy to me. I ended up with the Jenn-air 460P (last years, on half price blowout) which has been nothing less than a delight (but it weighs a TON). You might check www.thegrillingweb.com, they have forums where your grill *may* be discussed, as well as extensive discussions of lots of surprises folks find *after* they buy - might pay to evaluate some of their issues, and check how your prospective grill measures up. All that said - I haven't cooked on the Coleman, so my thoughts are only about grill selection in general... - Bo |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"bruman" > wrote in message
lkaboutcooking.com... > Hi Matt > > I am also looking at this grill. I saw it the other day at Loew's. The one > they had out on display also had the rotiserie motor and spit setup. If it > really comes with the deep fat fryer AND the rotiserie in the standard > 499.00 package then this might be the grill for me. I also am skeptical > about the dual cooking areas. I also noticed that it had no thermometer. I > would love to hear more on this thread. > > Anyone else??? > > Bruce Consumer reports rated the $279 Lowes Coleman grill highly for the money. But when I went looking the only Coleman in stock was the $399 one, (similar to the one you ask about but without the fryer and rotisserie, and a bit smaller). I finally decided that for $279 I'd take the chance, but there were construction features I didn't like in a grill that cost much more than that. Mainly the cheap feeling lid, including lightweight end castings, and simple hinge pin arrangement - doesn't seem 4-500 dollar sturdy to me. I ended up with the Jenn-air 460P (last years, on half price blowout) which has been nothing less than a delight (but it weighs a TON). You might check www.thegrillingweb.com, they have forums where your grill *may* be discussed, as well as extensive discussions of lots of surprises folks find *after* they buy - might pay to evaluate some of their issues, and check how your prospective grill measures up. All that said - I haven't cooked on the Coleman, so my thoughts are only about grill selection in general... - Bo |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"bruman" > wrote in message
lkaboutcooking.com... > Hi Matt > > I am also looking at this grill. I saw it the other day at Loew's. The one > they had out on display also had the rotiserie motor and spit setup. If it > really comes with the deep fat fryer AND the rotiserie in the standard > 499.00 package then this might be the grill for me. I also am skeptical > about the dual cooking areas. I also noticed that it had no thermometer. I > would love to hear more on this thread. > > Anyone else??? > > Bruce Consumer reports rated the $279 Lowes Coleman grill highly for the money. But when I went looking the only Coleman in stock was the $399 one, (similar to the one you ask about but without the fryer and rotisserie, and a bit smaller). I finally decided that for $279 I'd take the chance, but there were construction features I didn't like in a grill that cost much more than that. Mainly the cheap feeling lid, including lightweight end castings, and simple hinge pin arrangement - doesn't seem 4-500 dollar sturdy to me. I ended up with the Jenn-air 460P (last years, on half price blowout) which has been nothing less than a delight (but it weighs a TON). You might check www.thegrillingweb.com, they have forums where your grill *may* be discussed, as well as extensive discussions of lots of surprises folks find *after* they buy - might pay to evaluate some of their issues, and check how your prospective grill measures up. All that said - I haven't cooked on the Coleman, so my thoughts are only about grill selection in general... - Bo |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Don't waste your money. Buy a weber and have a grill that will be with you a
looooong time and do what you ask of it. Very versatile. Larry "bruman" > wrote in message lkaboutcooking.com... > Hi Matt > > I am also looking at this grill. I saw it the other day at Loew's. The one > they had out on display also had the rotiserie motor and spit setup. If it > really comes with the deep fat fryer AND the rotiserie in the standard > 499.00 package then this might be the grill for me. I also am skeptical > about the dual cooking areas. I also noticed that it had no thermometer. I > would love to hear more on this thread. > > Anyone else??? > > Bruce > |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
jdoe wrote:
> Don't waste your money. Buy a weber and have a grill that will be with you a > looooong time and do what you ask of it. Very versatile. Does Weber make a grill with two cooking chambers, one with a rotisserie and a deep well cooker that can be used for stewing, boiling or frying? Matthew |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
No but they make a grill that GRILLS as far as the other stuff........what
does it matter if it falls apart or doesn't do what it's main intent is well? "Matthew L. Martin" > wrote in message ... > jdoe wrote: > > > Don't waste your money. Buy a weber and have a grill that will be with you a > > looooong time and do what you ask of it. Very versatile. > > Does Weber make a grill with two cooking chambers, one with a rotisserie > and a deep well cooker that can be used for stewing, boiling or frying? > > Matthew |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
jdoe wrote:
> No but they make a grill that GRILLS as far as the other stuff........what > does it matter if it falls apart or doesn't do what it's main intent is > well? My experience with Coleman gassers is excellent. I have two, one at home, one at my lake house. Both are approaching 10 years old with minimal problems. Weber makes a fine product. So does Coleman. Coleman is making a product that has features I want and Weberisn't. That seems like an excellent reason to be considering a Coleman. After all, you don't buy a Toyota (extremely reliable) if you want a flat four engine and four wheel drive. BTW, top posting in this newsgroup is rude. Matthew |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Matt
I hope we get someone that has one of these to chime in. I am seriously thinking about this grill and when you consider that to get a good gas grill you have to pay at least 400.00 and up I really don't want to make a mistake. The dual area idea is unique in case you are grilling two different dishes. I looked at this grill for awhile the other day and each cooking area in itself is not very big (about 18 02 19 inches square. I'm concerned with how it works when you are cooking with indirect heat which I like to do a lot of. I'm a charcoal man myself but during the week it would be nice to do some grilling with minimal setup time. That's why I'm looking at gas. Do you have any pointers you could give. Since you have two gassers your opinions would be greatly appreciated. Bruce |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
bruman wrote:
> Matt > > I hope we get someone that has one of these to chime in. I am seriously > thinking about this grill and when you consider that to get a good gas > grill you have to pay at least 400.00 and up I really don't want to make a > mistake. The dual area idea is unique in case you are grilling two > different dishes. I looked at this grill for awhile the other day and each > cooking area in itself is not very big (about 18 02 19 inches square. I'm > concerned with how it works when you are cooking with indirect heat which > I like to do a lot of. I gave up on indirect cooking on gas because of the configuration of the burners in my grills. It's a long horseshoe burner that runs side to side. I bought charcoal smokers for indirect cooking. I suspect that the front to back burners in this gasser would work well for smaller roasts. I would tend to use the rotisserie for chickens, pork loins, etc. > I'm a charcoal man myself but during the week it > would be nice to do some grilling with minimal setup time. That's why I'm > looking at gas. Do you have any pointers you could give. Since you have > two gassers your opinions would be greatly appreciated. I really like the idea of being able to use a rotisserie and grill at the same time. That was the first appeal. The deep well cooker is something that I'm sure I would use a lot more often than the side burners I have now. The way I look at that device is that it is three cookers in one. If it does all three tasks well, I think it would be worth the money. Matthew -- Thermodynamics and/or Golf for dummies: There is a game You can't win You can't break even You can't get out of the game |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
bruman wrote:
> Matt > > I hope we get someone that has one of these to chime in. I am seriously > thinking about this grill and when you consider that to get a good gas > grill you have to pay at least 400.00 and up I really don't want to make a > mistake. The dual area idea is unique in case you are grilling two > different dishes. I looked at this grill for awhile the other day and each > cooking area in itself is not very big (about 18 02 19 inches square. I'm > concerned with how it works when you are cooking with indirect heat which > I like to do a lot of. I gave up on indirect cooking on gas because of the configuration of the burners in my grills. It's a long horseshoe burner that runs side to side. I bought charcoal smokers for indirect cooking. I suspect that the front to back burners in this gasser would work well for smaller roasts. I would tend to use the rotisserie for chickens, pork loins, etc. > I'm a charcoal man myself but during the week it > would be nice to do some grilling with minimal setup time. That's why I'm > looking at gas. Do you have any pointers you could give. Since you have > two gassers your opinions would be greatly appreciated. I really like the idea of being able to use a rotisserie and grill at the same time. That was the first appeal. The deep well cooker is something that I'm sure I would use a lot more often than the side burners I have now. The way I look at that device is that it is three cookers in one. If it does all three tasks well, I think it would be worth the money. Matthew -- Thermodynamics and/or Golf for dummies: There is a game You can't win You can't break even You can't get out of the game |
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Matthew L. Martin" > wrote in message ... > The deep well cooker is > something that I'm sure I would use a lot more often than the side > burners I have now. What is wrong with a dutch oven on the side burner? -CAL |
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Matthew L. Martin" > wrote in message ... > The deep well cooker is > something that I'm sure I would use a lot more often than the side > burners I have now. What is wrong with a dutch oven on the side burner? -CAL |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
cl wrote:
> What is wrong with a dutch oven on the side burner? > The major problem with virtually any side burner that I have seen is that they only work well at anything less than full bore when there is little to no wind. The windier it is the more likely the flame will be blown out. IME, it is nearly impossible to simmer on a side burner in anything other than dead calm. In theory, the deep well cooker is very well protected from wind and should be considerably safer to use at settings less than high. I'd really like to know that it is safer to use in practice. In theory, there is no difference between practice and theory. In practice, there is often little relationship between theory and practice. Matthew |
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
cl wrote:
> What is wrong with a dutch oven on the side burner? > The major problem with virtually any side burner that I have seen is that they only work well at anything less than full bore when there is little to no wind. The windier it is the more likely the flame will be blown out. IME, it is nearly impossible to simmer on a side burner in anything other than dead calm. In theory, the deep well cooker is very well protected from wind and should be considerably safer to use at settings less than high. I'd really like to know that it is safer to use in practice. In theory, there is no difference between practice and theory. In practice, there is often little relationship between theory and practice. Matthew |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Steaks on Coleman stove | General Cooking | |||
Coleman roadtrip LXE regulator freezing | Barbecue | |||
Coleman Beef OK w/Weber Grill? | Barbecue | |||
I love my new Coleman 5100 | Barbecue | |||
PING John Coleman: when was your cholesterol ever over 400?!] | Vegan |