Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

This is of course very broad, and incomplete because there are teas
that come from neither India or China, but I think it'd be interesting
to discuss the differences between these two primary tea sources.
Being a dilettante, I'll start with a generalization: Indian tea is
stronger than Chinese (generally). Usually, I've found, Indian tea is
one teaspoon per cup and Chinese is more like a tablespoon (if not
more).

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

Ferris92 wrote:
> This is of course very broad, and incomplete because there are teas
> that come from neither India or China, but I think it'd be interesting
> to discuss the differences between these two primary tea sources.
> Being a dilettante, I'll start with a generalization: Indian tea is
> stronger than Chinese (generally). Usually, I've found, Indian tea is
> one teaspoon per cup and Chinese is more like a tablespoon (if not
> more).

George Orwell in his essay on how to brew a perfect cup of tea, said to
use Indian or Ceylon tea, not Chinese.


stePH, just sayin'
NP: King Crimson, "Facts of Life"
in cup: 2003 sheng brick pu-er from Tao of Tea, 4th infusion

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

"Ferris92" > writes:

> This is of course very broad, and incomplete because there are teas
> that come from neither India or China, but I think it'd be interesting
> to discuss the differences between these two primary tea sources.
> Being a dilettante, I'll start with a generalization: Indian tea is
> stronger than Chinese (generally). Usually, I've found, Indian tea is
> one teaspoon per cup and Chinese is more like a tablespoon (if not
> more).

That generalization would be a lot weaker, I think, if you measured
the amount of tea by weight rather than volume. On the whole, with
Chinese manufacturing methods the dry leaf tends to be fluffier.

/Lew
---
Lew Perin /
http://www.panix.com/~perin/babelcarp.html

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

IMHO if you add ANYTHING to tea you turn it into a concoction. Sugar
and milk chemically react to tea changing the taste. If you're a Brit
you say for the better. I drink my share of Bubble and Chai but it
ain't tea. Indian teas are black with less moisture content than
Chinese green and Oolong. I can't remember the last time I've seen any
Indian tea of any grade bobble in the pot with a SG1. You can't get
any more dense and heavy than commercial Indian CTC. That one is
interesting because the granules will immediately suspend in the pot
before falling like a rock.

Jim

Lewis Perin wrote:
> "Ferris92" > writes:
>
> > This is of course very broad, and incomplete because there are teas
> > that come from neither India or China, but I think it'd be interesting
> > to discuss the differences between these two primary tea sources.
> > Being a dilettante, I'll start with a generalization: Indian tea is
> > stronger than Chinese (generally). Usually, I've found, Indian tea is
> > one teaspoon per cup and Chinese is more like a tablespoon (if not
> > more).
>
> That generalization would be a lot weaker, I think, if you measured
> the amount of tea by weight rather than volume. On the whole, with
> Chinese manufacturing methods the dry leaf tends to be fluffier.
>
> /Lew
> ---
> Lew Perin /
> http://www.panix.com/~perin/babelcarp.html

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

As lamented in the teafreaks group on LJ, I cannot find a good green
tea from India. I found lovely white teas, but green teas from India
are terrible, so far. My 2 cents is that most of these greens have been
CTC and green tea doesn't lend itself well to cutting because it causes
so much astringency.

1) Any recommendations of good Indian greens?
2) Anyone else agree or disagree?

Otherwise, I find that Indian teas, especially first flush black teas
and white teas, are very fruity and malty, whereas Chinese teas tend to
have a much broader ranges of flavors. But my sampling of Indian teas
has been small, so I'm open to experiences that change my perception.

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

"Jason F in Los Angeles" > skrev i en meddelelse
ups.com...
> As lamented in the teafreaks group on LJ, I cannot find a good green
> tea from India. I found lovely white teas, but green teas from India
> are terrible, so far. My 2 cents is that most of these greens have been
> CTC and green tea doesn't lend itself well to cutting because it causes
> so much astringency.
>
> 1) Any recommendations of good Indian greens?
> 2) Anyone else agree or disagree?

I have tried and enjoyed a selection of green Darjeeling teas from the
German online shop www.nurnatur.de. Their certified organic teas come from
the Seeyok estate. The taste is lovely, herbal and rather subtle, but not so
flowery and complex as good Chines or Japanese greens can be. They are
orthodox teas, not CTC. I would definitely recommend them at least for
trying, however I do not know whether they ship abroad (they certainly did
that about four years ago).

Gyorgy

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

Jason F in Los
1/12/06


> As lamented in the teafreaks group on LJ, I cannot find a good green
> tea from India. I found lovely white teas, but green teas from India
> are terrible, so far. My 2 cents is that most of these greens have been
> CTC and green tea doesn't lend itself well to cutting because it causes
> so much astringency.
>
> 1) Any recommendations of good Indian greens?
> 2) Anyone else agree or disagree?
>
> Otherwise, I find that Indian teas, especially first flush black teas
> and white teas, are very fruity and malty, whereas Chinese teas tend to
> have a much broader ranges of flavors. But my sampling of Indian teas
> has been small, so I'm open to experiences that change my perception.
>


Hi Jason,

I don't know of any fine truly green Indian teas, but I'd say this: While
Nilgiri and Assam teas are truly black -- oxidized to the max -- most
Darjeelings nowadays are on the green side, especially first flushes. Just
look at the leaf itself. Green bits abound. So, although we call it "black,"
Darjeeling teas are only partially oxidized...and you know what that makes
them, right? BTW, I've heard it said that in times past Darj's were truly
black, but modern taste demands otherwise.

Michael

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

Gyorgy wrote:
>I have tried and enjoyed a selection of green Darjeeling teas from the
>German online shop www.nurnatur.de. Their certified organic teas come from
>the Seeyok estate. The taste is lovely, herbal and rather subtle, but not so
>flowery and complex as good Chines or Japanese greens can be.

I fully agree, and I have tasted all green DJs I could get my hands on.
They're still working on it though, who knows.
Same applies to DJ Oolongs. Whatever they try up here IMO it's still
more Darjeeling than Ooolong. Especially when it comes to Gong-Fu most
if not all chinese Oolongs have been grown and manufactured to be
prepared that way. These days I still run into Darjeeling tea masters
who don't know too much about GF.
BTW: I found quite a few non-Oolong DJs who take Gong-Fu a lot better
than their Oolong brethren.
But then I enjoy my black and Oolong DJs for what they are, brillant
jewels in the world of teas.

Karsten / Darjeeling

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

Space Cowboy wrote:
> IMHO if you add ANYTHING to tea you turn it into a concoction. Sugar
> and milk chemically react to tea changing the taste. If you're a Brit
> you say for the better. I drink my share of Bubble and Chai but it
> ain't tea.

semi-OT (as it concerns that "other" drink) but yesterday one of the
ladies in the office here was sending another out to get "a coffee" and
specified a "white chocolate mocha". I commented, "I thought you were
having *coffee*."


stePH
in cup: Twinings Earl Grey

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

I've found that I really love darjeeling first flushes moreso than any
others, especially the Namring Estate one that they carry at
disneyland. It's got a lot of green in it, too. Gongfu
darjeeling...sounds like fun :)

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

"Ferris92" > wrote in message
oups.com...
> This is of course very broad, and incomplete because there are teas
> that come from neither India or China, but I think it'd be interesting
> to discuss the differences between these two primary tea sources.
> Being a dilettante, I'll start with a generalization: Indian tea is
> stronger than Chinese (generally). Usually, I've found, Indian tea is
> one teaspoon per cup and Chinese is more like a tablespoon (if not
> more).
>

Ferris92, I admire you for being a dilettante. Well done! Your question is a
superb one.

As a child I was constantly fed dark Indian tea on a cold and damp island in
the North Atlantic. These days, every cell in my body aches for the dark
brew. I like it strong, dark, and manly. But is it a good thing? Like you, I
have decided to do the decent thing and try Chinese tea, but where to start?
For me, it has to be strong, full-bodied, forthright, upstanding, stern
even. I know some of you, here on this esteemed group, have refined
palettes and probably refined sensitivities, too. But I need to start with a
proletarian or plebian tea. I need a tea that riff-raff like me can feel at
home with.



You, the wise of the tea world, I need your wisdom. Which Chinese tea should
I start with?



Oh! This is such a salacious subject. I am helplessly brewing a pot after
only reading ten messages.



Christopher

www.teamadness.com

Slightly true stories of tea drinking.

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

Christopher Richards wrote:
> "Ferris92" > wrote in message
> oups.com...
>
>>This is of course very broad, and incomplete because there are teas
>>that come from neither India or China, but I think it'd be interesting
>>to discuss the differences between these two primary tea sources.
>>Being a dilettante, I'll start with a generalization: Indian tea is
>>stronger than Chinese (generally). Usually, I've found, Indian tea is
>>one teaspoon per cup and Chinese is more like a tablespoon (if not
>>more).
>>
>
>
> Ferris92, I admire you for being a dilettante. Well done! Your question is a
> superb one.
>
> As a child I was constantly fed dark Indian tea on a cold and damp island in
> the North Atlantic. These days, every cell in my body aches for the dark
> brew. I like it strong, dark, and manly. But is it a good thing? Like you, I
> have decided to do the decent thing and try Chinese tea, but where to start?
> For me, it has to be strong, full-bodied, forthright, upstanding, stern
> even. I know some of you, here on this esteemed group, have refined
> palettes and probably refined sensitivities, too. But I need to start with a
> proletarian or plebian tea. I need a tea that riff-raff like me can feel at
> home with.
>
>
>
> You, the wise of the tea world, I need your wisdom. Which Chinese tea should
> I start with?

Lapsang Souchong - smells of bonfires and Laphroaig

anne
>
>
>
> Oh! This is such a salacious subject. I am helplessly brewing a pot after
> only reading ten messages.
>
>
>
> Christopher
>
> www.teamadness.com
>
> Slightly true stories of tea drinking.
>
>

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

Christopher Richards wrote:
> For me, it has to be strong, full-bodied, forthright, upstanding, stern
> even. I know some of you, here on this esteemed group, have refined
> palettes and probably refined sensitivities, too. But I need to start with a
> proletarian or plebian tea. I need a tea that riff-raff like me can feel at
> home with.

How about Yunnan? My coffee-drinking friend swears by it.

--crymad

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

> A good honest Keemun is what he wants. Nice and thick and winey and/or
> chocolatey. Can't go wrong. If it's gonna be a Yunnan, he's more apt to
> find
> a mapley one in the blond leaf style known as Royal or Golden. Otherwise,
> more likely peppery. What do you think? Just thoughts.
>
> Michael

Thanks for the recommendations for Yunann. I think I may have tried Lapsang
Souchong, some time ago but don't remember it. I'll get both on my next
foray to Chinatown.



On Sunday, I went to Viks Distributors in Berkeley. The regal matriarch was
not present. I stocked up on some Brooke Bond Red Label (my staple). The
package says " A special select blend of 'CTC' Tea from Assam for that
distinctive taste and color.



I also bought some Wagh Bakri strong CTC Leaf Tea. It has a beautiful
package. It's Assam too but not as flavorful as Red Label. I picked up some
Jivraj9 Tea. The beautiful young lady on the package may have swayed me.
This tea is "Hygienically" packaged! Makes one think about those other teas
doesn't it ? Are you drinking filthy tea? It may taste better? I don't know.
I haven't opened my packet of Jivraj 9 tea yet. It does say it is
"exotically' fresh. I just love the language. I can imagine such a tea
drinker saying things like, "How delicious to meet you." This is also 'CTC'
leaf pure Assam.



Not to be too stuck in my ways, I went a bit wild and bought some Tea India
Masala Chai Tea. It was a mistake. Why mess tea up? I went with the missus.
She bought a package of PG tips. Good tea, but in a bag! She's American so I
have to cut her some slack.

Indian vs Chinese Tea
 

>Are you drinking filthy tea?

No, I'm sure the monkeys wash before going back to work...

--Blair